Controversial aviary decision ‘rescinded’ after legal challenge

Sefton Council has reversed its decision to close Southport’s Botanic Gardens aviary following a legal challenge, with a public consultation now planned on its future.

Share
Controversial aviary decision ‘rescinded’ after legal challenge
Aviary at Botanic Gardens (image: Sefton Council)

Sefton Council has announced it has backed down over a controversial decision to close the aviary at Southport’s Botanic Gardens following a legal challenge.

In a statement issued today, Friday 13 November, the council confirmed that the decision had been ‘rescinded’ and that it would now hold a public consultation over the aviary’s future.

The announcement is something of a significant reversal for the local authority, which had previously said closing the aviary was an ‘operational decision’ not requiring public consultation.

In a statement posted on social media, the council said: ‘As has already been publicised, Sefton Council has received a legal challenge over an operational decision to close the Aviary at Botanic Gardens in Southport.’

The statement continues: ‘Fighting a legal challenge requires significant expense’, describing this as a ‘burden on the Sefton taxpayer.’

‘As a result of this challenge the operational decision in question has been rescinded by the Local Authority’ it adds.

Screenshot from the post on social media (Image: Screenshot)

The decision follows months of opposition to the aviary’s closure, including protests, petitions, and political challenges, as well as much comment and speculation on social media.

As previously reported by the Monitor, the original decision to close the 87-year-old aviary was tucked away in a single line of Sefton Council’s February budget report, with a projected saving of £60k a year.

The decision however took many by surprise when it was announced in June, prompting months of protests, petitions and political wrangling. Councillors rejected a motion aimed at securing funding for the aviary by Labour councillors, who hold the majority, at a full council meeting in July. Council leader Cllr Marion Atkinson spoke out at the meeting strongly in favour of the closure, citing animal welfare grounds.

An attempt by Sefton Lib Dems in September to bring the decision-making process back before a scrutiny committee was defeated after Labour councillors voted against. In October, a legal challenge was brought by the Botanic Gardens Community Association (BGCA), alongside the Save Our Aviary campaign, who said they’d issued the claim after other attempts to resolve the matter with Sefton Council failed.

Sefton council has maintained that the closure was an operational budget decision which did not require public consultation, although now, following the legal challenge, it has agreed to consult after all.

The council had cited animal welfare concerns, the condition of the aviary’s infrastructure and increasing financial pressures on the local authority among its reasons for closure.

It has now confirmed that members of the public will be consulted on the aviary’s future, with the consultation covering issues including animal welfare, rising financial demands, the condition of the infrastructure and future operational challenges. Details of the consultation will be published ‘in due course’, the council said.

The council’s reversal of its controversial decision doesn’t necessarily mean the aviary’s future has been secured, of course, but it does now mean members of the public have an opportunity to give their views before its future is determined.


New to the Mersey Monitor? Welcome! The Monitor is a Merseyside-based and focused public interest news site operating on a not-for-profit basis. All our stories are free to read and we rely on the goodwill of reader donations to keep what we’re doing sustainable and free of any annoying paywalls. Anyone can sign up for free to receive our emails.
While all our stories are completely free to read, we do need your support, so we’ve recently launched the Brown Envelope Scrutiny Committee, a paid-membership option that allows you to support our work providing independent public interest news for Merseyside, while also receiving the monthly Brown Envelope Edition, a series of increasingly bizarre emails from our entirely fictional scrutiny committee; a Certificate of Endurance and your own personal membership number. It’s all a bit long-winded and ridiculous, you can find out more about it here: https://www.merseymonitor.com/we-want-to-send-you-a-brown-envelope/