Trouble with the bins on the Wirral

What’s going on with Wirral’s bins?

Share
Trouble with the bins on the Wirral
Wirral bins (Image: Wirral Council)

*A version of this article originally appeared in our Sunday newsletter ‘What links an aviary, Wirral’s bins, a Sefton hammer cage and a giant Liverpool mirror?’ on November 15th.


It’s fair to say there’s always trouble with the bins somewhere on Merseyside and Wirral is no exception, where there’s a lingering smell forming around a public consultation about bins collections.

Council leader Cllr Paula Basnett, and the rest of the Wirral Labour group, have come out against the planned changes to household waste collections. Cllr Basnett told the Echo last week that the proposal to reduce collections from every two weeks to every three was something her party doesn't agree with. The Wirral Labour group have even set up a petition, signed at time of publication by 71 people, calling on the council to ‘abandon’ the plan.

We perhaps wouldn't be surprised about residents, or even opposition politicians, objecting to changes to bin collections. But what about objections from the group actually leading the council?

The petition says: ‘We recognise the financial pressures facing local government, but we urge the Council to explore alternative savings and efficiency measures before reducing a vital frontline service relied upon by every household in Wirral.’

Cllr Paula Basnett, leader of Wirral Council (image: Wirral Council)

Last year, Wirral Council published a tender for a new waste collection contract, worth up to £350m over 16 years. Bidders were asked to price two alternatives: keeping fortnightly collections and using smaller bins, or keeping existing bins but only emptying them every three weeks. The decision on which option to adopt would be made later.

The wider deal also involves the council buying a waste depot in Birkenhead, owned by current contractor Biffa, doing it up and then leasing it back to them. In part this was about keeping the council’s future options open, but the plan also emerged from concerns around ensuring a fair bidding process for the waste contract. Biffa ended up as the only bidder.

The plan to award the contract to Biffa and to also buy its depot came before councillors in June, two years after an outline business case was considered and after a full business case was made in January 2025, with plenty of working groups in between. The Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport committee, when it met in June, recommended awarding the contract to Biffa, before it was due to go to Policy and Resources committee the following month.

Cllr Basnett chairs Policy and Resources, which brings together the chairs of all the other main committees and other senior councillors, overseeing major decisions about council policy, finances and spending. It effectively functions as a kind of decision-making cabinet. During this meeting in July, Wirral Conservative leader Cllr Simon Mountney asked why councillors were going to approve the contract before discussing the collection frequency options.

Interim director of operations Mike Cockburn explained that council officers would take some matters to the Finance Working Group and talk to councillors about the options at a later date.

Green councillor Ed Lamb joked that there should be ‘an extraordinary general meeting’ if the committee wanted to stray into concerns about bin collection frequencies. Labour councillor Steve Foulkes, meanwhile, pointed out that there had already been a significant amount of political consultation during the two years spent developing the contract.

The deal was agreed by the Policy and Resources committee by assent, meaning it didn’t come down to a vote as nobody dissented.

Wirral bins (image: Wirral Council)

According to a subsequent council notice, by 8 September the Finance Working Group had instructed officers to do a consultation about the frequency of collections. A month later, the chief executive formally authorised a public consultation on the two options, with the council favouring three-weekly collections, largely because this avoids the cost of replacing the bins.

Councillors had the opportunity to challenge the decision to hold this consultation before it took effect through a 'political call-in'. That didn’t happen, so the consultation decision went into effect on 14 October.

The Labour group petition calls on Wirral council to 'abandon proposals to reduce green general household waste collections from once every two weeks to once every three weeks', but the contract approved by councillors doesn’t contain an option that involves keeping things as they are. Unless this is a roundabout way of Labour saying they want the smaller bins option. The petition certainly doesn’t explain how choosing an option that isn't in the contract would impact on the Biffa deal.

As we know, the consultation options didn’t appear from nowhere, they were discussed at the July meetings, the Finance Working Group instructed officers to do a consultation in September, and councillors had an opportunity to challenge the chief executive’s October decision. Nobody did.

On an unrelated note, we nearly forgot to mention there's an 'all-out election', meaning all council seats are back up for grabs, in the borough in May.


New to the Mersey Monitor? Welcome! The Monitor is a Merseyside-based and focused public interest news site operating on a not-for-profit basis. All our stories are free to read and we rely on the goodwill of reader donations to keep what we’re doing sustainable and free of any annoying paywalls. Anyone can sign up for free to receive our emails.