What links an aviary, Wirral’s bins, a Sefton hammer cage and a giant Liverpool mirror?

They’re all in this Sunday’s Monitor newsletter of course - plus, what’s in a name and what’s getting decided in our names across Merseyside this week?

Share
What links an aviary, Wirral’s bins,  a Sefton hammer cage and a giant Liverpool mirror?

Howdy Mersey Monitorizens,

Welcome to this week’s newsletter.

Don’t worry, we’re not about to form a breakaway Bureaucratic Republic of Monitor and declare you all unwitting citizens this cold November evening. We’re just slowly running out of novel collective monikers for our dear readers...

We’ve had Monitorers, Monitorites, Monitoronis, Monitorians, Monitoroos (yikes), with Monitrons making more than one appearance in our Sunday newsletter. We were silently pondering whether anyone has actually noticed, until last week, when someone told us they had.

Feeling heard, we now want to listen to you. In particular, we’d quite like to know: do any of the Monitor monikers fit? Do you have a favourite? Any suggestions? Or should we quit while we’re ahead?

In true local democracy style, we've decided it’s as good a time as any for a public consultation on the matter. Do send your thoughts, preferably in a sealed brown envelope, to themerseymonitor@outlook.com. Alternatively, you can fill in our very important survey here, or just comment below.

Anyway, that’s enough drama for one Sunday. So we'll move seamlessly on from whatever we're calling ourselves, to what's being done in our names across Merseyside this week. In fact, there's been no shortage of drama here too.


Trouble with the bins

It’s fair to say there’s always trouble with the bins somewhere on Merseyside, and in recent weeks, we’ve been following a trail of waste. The Monitor archive is currently full of pictures of the same bins at an undisclosed Liverpool location and we hope to explain why soon enough (it’s not because they’re particularly pretty, we can tell you that much).

A sneak peek at one of the Liverpool bins in question (image: Mersey Monitor)

But, on the other side of the Mersey, there’s already a lingering smell around a public consultation about bins.

Council leader Cllr Paula Basnett, and the rest of the Wirral Labour group, have come out against the planned changes to household waste collections. Cllr Basnett told the Echo last week that the proposal to reduce collections from every two weeks to every three was something her party doesn't agree with. The Wirral Labour group have even set up a petition, signed at time of publication by 71 people, calling on the council to ‘abandon’ the plan.

We perhaps wouldn't be surprised about residents, or even opposition politicians, objecting to changes to bin collections. But what about objections from the group actually leading the council?

The petition says: ‘We recognise the financial pressures facing local government, but we urge the Council to explore alternative savings and efficiency measures before reducing a vital frontline service relied upon by every household in Wirral.’

Cllr Paula Basnett, leader of Wirral Council (image: Wirral Council)

Last year, Wirral Council published a tender for a new waste collection contract, worth up to £350m over 16 years. Bidders were asked to price two alternatives: keeping fortnightly collections and using smaller bins, or keeping existing bins but only emptying them every three weeks. The decision on which option to adopt would be made later.

The wider deal also involves the council buying a waste depot in Birkenhead, owned by current contractor Biffa, doing it up and then leasing it back to them. In part this was about keeping the council’s future options open, but the plan also emerged from concerns around ensuring a fair bidding process for the waste contract. Biffa ended up as the only bidder.

The plan to award the contract to Biffa and to also buy its depot came before councillors in June, two years after an outline business case was considered and after a full business case was made in January 2025, with plenty of working groups in between. The Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport committee, when it met in June, recommended awarding the contract to Biffa, before it was due to go to Policy and Resources committee the following month.

Cllr Basnett chairs Policy and Resources, which brings together the chairs of all the other main committees and other senior councillors, overseeing major decisions about council policy, finances and spending. It effectively functions as a kind of decision-making cabinet. During this meeting in July, Wirral Conservative leader Cllr Simon Mountney asked why councillors were going to approve the contract before discussing the collection frequency options.

Interim director of operations Mike Cockburn explained that council officers would take some matters to the Finance Working Group and talk to councillors about the options at a later date.

Green councillor Ed Lamb joked that there should be ‘an extraordinary general meeting’ if the committee wanted to stray into concerns about bin collection frequencies. Labour councillor Steve Foulkes, meanwhile, pointed out that there had already been a significant amount of political consultation during the two years spent developing the contract.

The deal was agreed by the Policy and Resources committee by assent, meaning it didn’t come down to a vote as nobody dissented.

Wirral bins (image: Wirral Council)

According to a subsequent council notice, by 8 September the Finance Working Group had instructed officers to do a consultation about the frequency of collections. A month later, the chief executive formally authorised a public consultation on the two options, with the council favouring three-weekly collections, largely because this avoids the cost of replacing the bins.

Councillors had the opportunity to challenge the decision to hold this consultation before it took effect through a 'political call-in'. That didn’t happen, so the consultation decision went into effect on 14 October.

The Labour group petition calls on Wirral council to 'abandon proposals to reduce green general household waste collections from once every two weeks to once every three weeks', but the contract approved by councillors doesn’t contain an option that involves keeping things as they are. Unless this is a roundabout way of Labour saying they want the smaller bins option. The petition certainly doesn’t explain how choosing an option that isn't in the contract would impact on the Biffa deal.

As we know, the consultation options didn’t appear from nowhere, they were discussed at the July meetings, the Finance Working Group instructed officers to do a consultation in September, and councillors had an opportunity to challenge the chief executive’s October decision. Nobody did.

On an unrelated note, we nearly forgot to mention there's an 'all-out election', meaning all council seats are back up for grabs, in the borough in May.


‘Two thirds of an aviary’ and a hammer cage in a hurry?

We’ve also been looking at decision-making over in Sefton again, reporting on a recent u-turn by the council over its controversial decision to close the Botanic Gardens aviary in Southport after a legal challenge by campaigners.

The council originally classed the closure as a cost-saving operational decision, aimed at clawing back £60,000 per year, and appearing as a single line in the wider budget report discussed at full council in February. When it was announced in June, however, it took many people by surprise and sparked an almighty row.

At a testy full council meeting in July, where opposition councillors unsuccessfully made the case for considering alternative options, council leader Cllr Marion Atkinson said the decision was as much about the birds' welfare as the cost.

Things got even more heated in September. The Lib Dems managed to get the decision called in for scrutiny, but the Labour majority voted to leave it unchanged. At the full council meeting two days later, Cllr Atkinson complained about the tone of the public outcry on social media, which was subsequently reported by the Echo and the BBC.

Campaigners revealed in October they had mounted a legal challenge, so things went relatively quiet while proceedings got underway.

Sefton Council leader Cllr Marion Atkinson (Imsge: Sefton Council)

That all changed on Friday, when the council announced it had ‘rescinded’ the decision because of the potential cost of legal proceedings. Although it maintains that closure is the right course of action, and that the original decision was operational rather than a ‘key’ one, it will now consult residents before deciding the birds’ fate.

Community Independent Cllr Joanne McCall, whose maiden speech at Sefton’s full council meeting in September concerned the aviary, told the Monitor she was relieved for residents, saying ‘it should never have come to this point’. She said she hoped it would be a ‘lesson learned’ for the council that it was ‘not immune to challenge’.

The Lib Dems, whose local heartlands are in Southport, have welcomed the decision on social media but also warned the consultation must be ‘thorough and transparent.’ Sefton Labour group’s Facebook page, meanwhile, has been silent so far on the u-turn.

It was quite timely for the Monitor anyway that details of the u-turn emerged late on Friday, as just a few hours earlier we’d been asking Sefton Council about another spending matter where the birds happened to crop up.

The hammer cage

This concerned almost £40,000 spent on replacing a broken hammer cage at Litherland Sports Park. Several residents had contacted us, one who said they were ‘mystified’ about why the council was spending so much on something they claimed was so little used.

Hammer cage, Litherland Sports Park (image: a Monitor reader)

‘Two thirds of an aviary’ was how one local resident described it, so we’d put that comparison to the council on Friday morning. By the afternoon, the question had become somewhat moot.

The concerns raised by local residents had prompted us to fire off a Freedom of Information (FOI) request and the response worked its way back to us last week. Among the documents was a contracts waiver form, which the council said also functioned as the business case for the hammer cage spending.

This money had its origins in the very same February budget where the aviary’s fate was buried in a hefty bundle of documents. Here the council approved more than £400,000 for essential works at its leisure facilities, including £37,700 on the hammer cage, or almost 10% of the total.

The need for a replacement was also raised in a cabinet member update to the council’s Adult Social Care and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 24 February. The report explained that a defective support had put the cage out of action and attempts to repair it had failed, leaving replacement as a possible solution at ‘substantial cost’.

We asked the council in our FOI for ‘any requests, proposals or correspondence from athletics clubs or other external organisations concerning the provision or replacement of the throwing cage’. The response was: ‘We do not hold this information.’

The council did tell us the facility had been used by Stanley High School, and Southport and Waterloo Athletic Club, in 2024, though we weren’t told how frequently. Its records showed the cage was out of use throughout 2025 until August 2026.

When we asked how the spending was justified, the council’s FOI response referred us to the waiver, which is where things became even more interesting.

Screenshot from the Sefton Council Contract Waiver (Image: Screenshot)

The waiver sought permission to depart from normal purchasing rules by awarding the contract directly to a supplier rather than doing a full tender. The reason given was the need to get the replacement installed ‘in order to have the cage available for this athletics seasons events’.

According to the business case, the cage was ‘essential’ for hosting the athletics meets. Such equipment wasn’t generally held in stock, but the proposed supplier already had ‘one on order’, potentially shortening the wait.

Two quotes were obtained. Sport & Play Ltd offered to supply and install the cage for £37,700 excluding VAT, with an estimated installation time of six weeks. Athletics Direct quoted £41,000, with an estimated eight-week wait.

The waiver lists the contract period as running from 21 April to 14 August 2026. The council’s FOI response suggests the replacement was available from some point in August, although we haven’t established exactly when it was installed, or whether it was ready for the athletics events cited in the business case.

There’s something else we haven’t yet been able to establish. Sefton confirmed the waiver was granted because Sport & Play could deliver more quickly than other suppliers, but the copy provided to the Monitor has no authorisation date, and the section for the procurement service manager’s review and signature is blank.

Screenshot from the Sefton council contract waiver we received (image: screenshot)

That doesn’t necessarily mean it wasn’t approved. Indeed, the council says it was. But the document doesn’t show when, or by who. It also says the supplier already had a cage on order, raising questions about the timing of the waiver and whether the equipment had already been ordered on the council’s behalf.

We put those questions to Sefton Council but hadn’t received a response by the time of publication.


Mirror mirror no more, but no affordable homes either?

A distinctive, vacant building on the corner of Leeds Street and Old Hall Street that resembles a giant curved mirror could soon be no more, after plans to replace it with two enormous residential towers reached new heights last week.

The building, originally constructed as a computer centre for Littlewoods, is earmarked for demolition to make way for 434 apartments across two buildings, one 25-storeys high and the other 19.

There's 663 bedrooms between them, and just seven car parking spaces, two of which would be reserved for disabled motorists.

The ‘mirror mirror’ building on the corner of Leeds Street and Old Hall Street (Image: Google Streetview)

If you’re wondering where all the residents’ cars are supposed to go, there is a reason for the limited parking. According to the planning documents, the development is designed around city-centre living, with plenty of public transport nearby and 330 cycle parking spaces instead. It’s an approach increasingly encouraged in planning policies aimed at reducing reliance on private cars.

The plans were backed by Liverpool’s planning committee in November last year, but the formal permission has only recently been issued following the completion of a Section 106 legal agreement. These agreements are used to secure contributions from developers towards things like local infrastructure and public amenities, and this one makes for interesting reading.

The developer, Liverpool I Ltd, has agreed to pay around £161,000 towards local improvements and to mitigate the impact of the scheme. That includes nearly £121,000 to address recreational pressure, £20,000 towards reviewing and implementing local parking controls, and another £20,000 for active travel schemes.

Birds Eye View of the development (image: Liverpool council planning portal)

But there are some much larger sums it won’t have to pay, at least for now. The council’s planning policies would have ordinarily required £868,000 for open space development and £347,000 towards tree planting, alongside provision for affordable housing.

However, the developer has argued the scheme wouldn’t be financially viable with those requirements, and following an independent assessment, the council has agreed. So, there are currently no affordable homes in either tower, although the agreement does allow for the finances to be reassessed, potentially securing additional contributions if the position improves.

And, if towers of 25 and 19 storeys already sound like significant additions to Liverpool's skyline, local councillors Nick Small and Christine Banks actually suggested the site would lend itself to something taller. In the report that went to planning for approval last November, they referred to the need to balance ambition against what developers could ‘realistically deliver’.

They’re likely tall enough for the potentially soon-to-be-residents to catch a decent view of Bramley Moore and the new Everton stadium and a fair bit more of the riverfront views too, but whether those moving in would be especially attracted by a view over one of the city centre’s busiest road junctions is another question entirely.


Rally and re-cap

Just a final quick one about a rally that we understand was attended by around 400 people on London Road in protest at planned cuts to the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine.

The Monitor was there on Tuesday, where we were busy taking notes and snapping photos, so we forgot to count, but it was a grand old turnout. Our multi-award-winning contributor Ashish Prabhu got the low-down and will be bringing you more on that soon.

Some of the protestors holding a sign against the rally over cuts st Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine on Tuesday (Image: Ashish Prabhu)

We’ve got loads lined up for you next week, the culmination of plenty of work finally starting to come to fruition, so do keep an eye on the site for more.

And in case you missed what we were reporting on this week, besides the aviary u-turn, do check out Patricia’s lovely story about the Kindfulness Coffee Club up in Bootle, which you can find here:

‘It makes you feel happy and cheerful and wanted'
The Monitor sips from a cup of Kindfulness in Bootle

We've also been taking a look at what’s going on down Victorian Road in New Brighton in a change of hands for two of the town’s best-known venues. More here:

New ‘heart’ for New Brighton as venues change hands
A newly formed company headed by the owner of Copeland Security has taken on two of New Brighton’s best-known venues

Brown envelopes

And of course we can’t let you go without a short update on the Brown Envelope Scrutiny Committee. It’s our daft paid membership scheme for the Mersey Monitor that helps keep all of our journalism free.

Members of the committee and its currently singular Cabinet Member were sent their first edition of our monthly Brown Envelope Edition last week. Certificates of Endurance are in process, and we might have a little update for you all on it all mid-week.

We should point out there’s a distinct lack of officers signed up. For a fiver a month, you’d be helping to support free public-interest news for Merseyside. You don’t actually have to do anything, other than read (or not read!) our occasional daft bureaucratic paperwork, sent out in the Brown Envelope Edition, but you will have the satisfaction of supporting the Monitor.

You can find out more about it all here:

We want to send you a Brown Envelope
The Monitor is establishing a scrutiny committee, but we’ve got something we need to tell you first

That’s us for the Sunday newsletter. We hope you’re off now to relax and have some lovely dreams tonight that aren’t too disturbed with hurried hammer cages, at-risk aviaries, giant mirrors or even more giant towers. And we certainly hope you don’t get stuck dreaming about the bins.